Propose to us!

Evaluation of Base4NFDI

In view of the complexity, but also the novelty of the processes for basic service development, Base4NFDI has committed itself in its project proposalto an evaluation of the decision-making processes and framework after two years:

"Given the novelty of its approach and to foster continuous adaptation and optimization of its structures, the young age and thus developing nature of the NFDI and its processes Base4NFDI, commits to an external evaluation of its governance and all decision-making processes after two years. The purpose of the evaluation is to objectively assess possible deficiencies particularly with respect to substantive and financial decisions. It will be handled by an external (likely commercial) provider with the appropriate experience in “programme evaluations” and no ties to any partners within Base4NFDI." (p. 102)

Based on the proposal text and the experience gained during the project so far, the following points are of particular interest:

  • Assessment of the cooperation and support between Base4NFDI and all involved stakeholders
  • Analysis of the process and resource management
  • Review of the work programme according to the proposal and the distribution of tasks within the team as well as efficiency and effectiveness
  • Evaluation of the submission and evaluation process for basic services

These objectives are intended to ensure a comprehensive and targeted evaluation of the services and processes of Base4NFDI. The results of the evaluation will be used to propose improvements to the processes in the second half of the project to increase the efficiency and success. For this reason, all teams and stakeholders involved (Base4NFDI Team Members, TEC, NFDI Sections, Basic Services Development Teams and Consortia Members) are both data providers and target group of the evaluation.
In the following section, we would like to inform you about the progress and current status of the evaluation.

We are pleased to announce that Technopolis has completed its evaluation of Base4NFDI's structure and mechanisms. Working closely with the Base4NFDI team, particularly the Base4NFDI Office, Technopolis assessed the social and technical governance of Base4NFDI in terms of its relevance, effectiveness, efficiency, and coherence.

The final report available on Zenodo, and will contain the final results and recommendations from the Technopolis Group.
The next step is for the Base4NFDI team to discuss the results and recommendations with the relevant stakeholders, in order to determine how Base4NFDI can adopt them.

The goal is to improve our processes in the second half of the project to increase its efficiency and success.

Evaluation timetable

Documents

In the following section you can find important documents abouts the concept and progress of the Base4NFDI evaluation.

  • Terms of Reference for public tender, September 2024, .pdf
  • Inception Report, February 2025, Zenodo
  • Final Report, August 2025, Zenodo
  • Presentation '​NFDI as a Learning System. Results and Lessons Learned from the Evaluation of Base4NFDI', CoRDI 2025 in Aachen, Link follows

About Technopolis

Technopolis Group provides evidence-based policy advice and insights with offices in Europe, Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean. Their experts support decision makers who want to tackle environmental or societal issues or look to achieve fair and sustainable growth through science, technology, innovation, health and education.
More information on their website.

We use cookies
...but only the cookies automatically set by Joomla for the session, which are not marketing cookies and cannot be avoided and are data protection compliant. Apart from this, this website does not use any other first-party or third-party cookies.
Ok